bigmerge
5f3ddb8b8d
El SDK CI - dev / build-and-test (pull_request) Failing after 14m31s
LTP/LTD-style belief grounding propagated along graph edges, with union-find independence-guarded corroboration. Package: core C algorithm (gep_core.h), a self-contained deterministic proof harness with recorded output, staged runtime integration, and gated .el patches for the beat hook and HTTP route. Per the author's own LEDGER.md: built + proven on a clone, GATED pending the engine/HNSW cutover — not wired into the live beat or routes. Preserved here as a spec/reference artifact, not a request to merge into the live path.
76 lines
4.8 KiB
Plaintext
76 lines
4.8 KiB
Plaintext
GROUNDED EDGE-PROPAGATION — PROOF LEDGER (task #50)
|
|
constants: BASE=0.10 LIKELY_MIN=0.34 GROUNDED_MIN=0.66 N_MIN=3 THETA=0.30 D=0.5
|
|
|
|
=== SCENARIO A — STRENGTHEN: convergent independent corroboration ===
|
|
seed: conjecture has NO grounding events; corroborators pre-grounded.
|
|
conjecture standing=0.1000 band=conjecture events=0 subthresh=0
|
|
beat 1 (t=+0s) 3 independent grounded corroborators appear
|
|
incident_edges=3 pos_mass=0.4050 (n_indep=3) neg_mass=0.0000 (n_indep=0) THETA=0.30 N_MIN=3
|
|
-> LTP (strengthen) standing 0.1000 (conjecture) -> 0.4842 (likely) [GRADUATED]
|
|
beat 2 (t=+60s) neighborhood grows to 5 corroborators
|
|
incident_edges=5 pos_mass=0.6750 (n_indep=5) neg_mass=0.0000 (n_indep=0) THETA=0.30 N_MIN=3
|
|
-> LTP (strengthen) standing 0.1496 (conjecture) -> 0.7379 (grounded) [GRADUATED]
|
|
beat 3 (t=+120s) support sustained (5)
|
|
incident_edges=5 pos_mass=0.6750 (n_indep=5) neg_mass=0.0000 (n_indep=0) THETA=0.30 N_MIN=3
|
|
-> LTP (strengthen) standing 0.2110 (conjecture) -> 0.7993 (grounded) [GRADUATED]
|
|
beat 4 (t=+720s) corroboration withdrawn (+10min)
|
|
incident_edges=0 pos_mass=0.0000 (n_indep=0) neg_mass=0.0000 (n_indep=0) THETA=0.30 N_MIN=3
|
|
-> isolated (no edges) standing 0.1612 (conjecture) -> 0.1612 (conjecture)
|
|
beat 5 (t=+3600s) still withdrawn (+1h)
|
|
incident_edges=0 pos_mass=0.0000 (n_indep=0) neg_mass=0.0000 (n_indep=0) THETA=0.30 N_MIN=3
|
|
-> isolated (no edges) standing 0.1263 (conjecture) -> 0.1263 (conjecture)
|
|
beat 6 (t=+14400s) still withdrawn (+4h)
|
|
incident_edges=0 pos_mass=0.0000 (n_indep=0) neg_mass=0.0000 (n_indep=0) THETA=0.30 N_MIN=3
|
|
-> isolated (no edges) standing 0.1130 (conjecture) -> 0.1130 (conjecture)
|
|
RESULT: grounding grew automatically past threshold and graduated,
|
|
then relaxed once the independent support stopped — living,
|
|
not a latched flag.
|
|
|
|
=== SCENARIO B — DECAY: convergent independent CONTRADICTION ===
|
|
seed: belief pre-grounded by a strong prior LTP event.
|
|
belief standing=0.9500 band=grounded events=1 subthresh=0
|
|
beat 1 (t=+0s) 3 independent contradictions
|
|
incident_edges=3 pos_mass=0.0000 (n_indep=0) neg_mass=0.5400 (n_indep=3) THETA=0.30 N_MIN=3
|
|
-> LTD (decay) standing 0.9500 (grounded) -> 0.4570 (likely) [DEMOTED]
|
|
beat 2 (t=+60s) contradiction broadens to 5
|
|
incident_edges=5 pos_mass=0.0000 (n_indep=0) neg_mass=0.9000 (n_indep=5) THETA=0.30 N_MIN=3
|
|
-> LTD (decay) standing 0.1461 (conjecture) -> 0.0000 (conjecture)
|
|
beat 3 (t=+120s) contradiction sustained (5)
|
|
incident_edges=5 pos_mass=0.0000 (n_indep=0) neg_mass=0.9000 (n_indep=5) THETA=0.30 N_MIN=3
|
|
-> LTD (decay) standing 0.0401 (conjecture) -> 0.0000 (conjecture)
|
|
beat 4 (t=+180s) contradiction sustained (5)
|
|
incident_edges=5 pos_mass=0.0000 (n_indep=0) neg_mass=0.9000 (n_indep=5) THETA=0.30 N_MIN=3
|
|
-> LTD (decay) standing 0.0000 (conjecture) -> 0.0000 (conjecture)
|
|
RESULT: grounding decayed grounded->likely->conjecture under
|
|
convergent independent contradiction. The door never shut
|
|
on the belief; its history is retained (events keep growing).
|
|
|
|
=== SCENARIO C — INDEPENDENCE GUARD (the load-bearing property) ===
|
|
Both sub-cases: N=5 corroborators, edge weight 0.30, corroborator
|
|
standing ~0.90. ONLY difference: whether the 5 are independent.
|
|
|
|
-- C1: 5 DISTINCT independent corroborators --
|
|
conjecture standing=0.1000 band=conjecture events=0 subthresh=0
|
|
beat 1 (t=+0s) 5 independent corroborators (no inter-links)
|
|
incident_edges=5 pos_mass=1.3500 (n_indep=5) neg_mass=0.0000 (n_indep=0) THETA=0.30 N_MIN=3
|
|
-> LTP (strengthen) standing 0.1000 (conjecture) -> 0.9741 (grounded) [GRADUATED]
|
|
|
|
-- C2: 5 corroborators, but mutually-linked (echo of ONE source) --
|
|
conjecture standing=0.1000 band=conjecture events=0 subthresh=0
|
|
beat 1 (t=+0s) 5 echoed (mutually-linked) corroborators
|
|
incident_edges=5 pos_mass=0.2700 (n_indep=1) neg_mass=0.0000 (n_indep=0) THETA=0.30 N_MIN=3
|
|
-> sub-threshold (no shift) standing 0.1000 (conjecture) -> 0.1000 (conjecture)
|
|
|
|
-- C3: ONE corroborator, reached by 5 parallel edges --
|
|
conjecture standing=0.1000 band=conjecture events=0 subthresh=0
|
|
beat 1 (t=+0s) same node, 5 parallel edges
|
|
incident_edges=5 pos_mass=0.2700 (n_indep=1) neg_mass=0.0000 (n_indep=0) THETA=0.30 N_MIN=3
|
|
-> sub-threshold (no shift) standing 0.1000 (conjecture) -> 0.1000 (conjecture)
|
|
|
|
RESULT: identical raw fan-in (5) and mass inputs; C1 grounds because
|
|
the corroboration is INDEPENDENT (5 components), C2/C3 do not
|
|
because it collapses to ONE source. Circular self-reinforcement
|
|
cannot manufacture grounding.
|
|
|
|
DONE.
|