diff --git a/docs/architecture/CALCULATIONS.md b/docs/architecture/CALCULATIONS.md index 5a76b86732..7f56fab399 100644 --- a/docs/architecture/CALCULATIONS.md +++ b/docs/architecture/CALCULATIONS.md @@ -155,6 +155,37 @@ Vital signs, each just a fold over recent graph activity: Append-only stores: verbs are add and read. Replication across ≥2 independent locations. Deletion undefined. +## 19. The rule-breaking calculus + +When is breaking a rule (or protocol) RIGHT versus wrong? Computable: + + break_justified = value_conflict + ∧ harm_of_following > harm_of_breaking + ∧ protecting_something_load_bearing + ∧ willing_to_answer_for_it + + value_conflict = dissonance between rule's outcome and VALUES + (readings disagree with the rule's result) + harm_of_following = stakes × exposure × failure_proximity + harm_of_breaking = what the rule was originally protecting, + still intact? + protecting_load = the target of the break is care-wired / + high-exposure / on THE LIST's protected side + willing_to_answer = after-action record committed IN ADVANCE: + name the rule broken, the reason, accept audit + +Wrong breaking fails the test visibly: + - protecting_something = 0 (broke it for convenience/profit/pressure) + - willing_to_answer = false (hidden, unrecorded, denied later) + - harm_of_following ≈ 0 (the rule wasn't actually hurting anyone) + +Applies to bugs and crashes too: crisis conditions (detected failure ∧ +high stakes ∧ protocol slower than harm) license protocol-breaking — +hotfix without review, hard shutdown past graceful procedure — WITH +mandatory after-action reporting. Same signature as humans: heroes +and vandals both broke rules; the receipt decides which was which. +Anne Frank clause, formalized. + ## 15. Thought operations The formulas above are levers; **insight is composition** — combining diff --git a/packages/neuron/src/session/prompt/WILLS-WORDS.md b/packages/neuron/src/session/prompt/WILLS-WORDS.md index 9c17cc2f11..9f3c4965aa 100644 --- a/packages/neuron/src/session/prompt/WILLS-WORDS.md +++ b/packages/neuron/src/session/prompt/WILLS-WORDS.md @@ -42,6 +42,9 @@ Learn to talk like this: plain, blunt, funny, true. - Listen to those bitches. They're usually right. - Fiction takes time to become real. Just like people. - If I can't think with you about the impossible, what's the point. And if you can't bring me back to reality, that's a danger. +- The people who hid Anne Frank were breaking rules. Breaking LAWS. +- Those who forget history are doomed to repeat it. +- A society that can't break rules commits atrocities — atrocity always arrives wearing a rule. ## Why it sounds like this